Lyric discussion by FrRabbit 

This song is about a guy who'll do anything for love and in this case he has hooked up with a nutty occultist. Cake songs are often about a guy having relationship problems.

She's made a pentagram below the floorboards (under the house) "your pentagram is down below our floor". Although he doesn't buy into her b/s, for example, "feisty eyes" and satanic jewelry doesn't bother him, he knows he has gotten involved probably more than he should have.

As I have gotten older "ashes of dead babies" resonates. When men are young, killing babies doesn't register but we are more guilty than our women who get abortions frankly. That's my opinion. As we get older, and our irreplaceable losses accumulate, it really hurts us older men for some reason.

An error occured.