Lyric discussion by KathyRCarr 

I hate to say this, but, while Phils words are beautifully haunting and heartbreaking they drag down with his tempo. Listen to Gordon Lightfoot's version. And while I love his up-tempo beat he discarded two of the verses which leave a HUGE HOLE in the middle of the tale.

@KathyRCarr oh no, Gordons Lightfoot's vesion is to busy and fast....

An error occured.