Lyric discussion by Pooer 

I think one point that is wrong that has been repeated a lot here, is that she was ever in love with him. She wasn't, he was. That's why she had a place in HIS life, but he never made her think twice. In over words, she didn't give him a "second thought".

And the line-

"Trying hard to recreate What had yet to be created once in her life"

He was trying to rekindle an old romance that never existed in the first place. Not even once in her life.

That last part could be interpreted in two ways-

"not once in her life had she loved HIM" or "not once in her life had she loved ANYONE". She really sounds heartless, and he is truly a fool caring for such a person. I bet he has cats.

An error occured.