Lyric discussion by sobot 

I agree with Surrenderyourego and LittleBriddie. But I see another moment here:

"We make up for so much time a little too late" could mean that at certain point she decided to rush into something after years of restrain. She had a very negative experience due to her being inexperienced and now she is desperate and sees no other exit but to return to faith (the "...but I believe again..." part).

An error occured.