Lyric discussion by JAM4321 

Maybe this is too literal, but I always heard this song as Ryan indulging in suicidal fantasies. Almost like Sylvia represents giving in to mental illness and not fighting it anymore. Not living in reality, and instead going with "her" to France or Spain and dancing in some imaginary mansion on a hill. I always took the "slip me a pill, and get me pretty loaded on gin and maybe she'd give me a bath" as the act of suicide itself. As in, taking pills, drinking, and slipping away in a bath. Also, the lines about swimming reminds me of a part of The Bell Jar where she is at the beach and literally tries to drown herself while swimming. In the song, when he describes "while she was swimming away, she'd be winking at me telling me it would all be okay, out on the horizon and fading away" as a ridiculously romanticized version of drowning. In both instances, the "death" occurs in a sort of gentle, comforting manner. It seems kind of like a giant suicidal ideation, and Sylvia represents a dreamy end.

AGREE

@JAM4321 I absolutely agree with your comment as well. Spot on!

@JAM4321 Wow, really well written. 'going with "her" to France or Spain... I can relate so well - that's where the song takes me, to this non-reality fantasy, exotic travels, skinny dipping on the boat ...how could you not get taken away with this song, whether relating from a mental illness perspective or an escaping reality perspective. Either way, you say it very well - better than I could

An error occured.