Lyric discussion by kristinwithni 

This song is definitely about a failed relationship and struggling to accept that it's over. He's seeing her again after significant time has passed and realizes she has moved on either somewhat or completely, and he's wondering why it really ended in the first place when he realizes she is with somebody else. For whatever reason, it didn't work out and although he thought initially it was the best thing to do, he is realizing the good times outweighed the bad seeing her, being around her again. "Does it end like this?" It's like he can't believe it's really over seeing her blow kisses to somebody else like she did him.

If you always knew the truth then the world will spin around you Are you dizzy yet?

-If you always knew how much I loved you, “the world would spin around you,” are you dizzy yet? Are you really taking this all in? Does this matter to you, did my feelings ever really matter to you when push came to shove?

Respectfully, so honestly, I'm calling out Do you hear the conversation we talk around? I'll back away to the safety of a quiet house If there's half a chance in this moment When your eyes meet mine, we show it off

-He knows that they're discussing their relationship, but neither one of them will acknowledge the possibility of trying again for whatever reason. They have probably broken up before, and knew immediately if they were to be in contact with each other that would happen. It begins with small talk, eventually delving into something deeper. She says she’s over him. He says “seriously? Respectfully, some honesty, I’m calling out, do you hear the conversation we talk around?” hoping she would be honest with him instead of talking about their conversation, actually HEAR it and understand it shows how they really feel about one another. They probably had issues with her being honest about how much she really cared for him at some point.

“I’ll back away to the safety of a quiet house” is that he’s going to back away and let her figure it out for herself, that they love one another and what it is they are avoiding talking about. “If there’s half a chance in this moment when your eyes meet mine, we show it off” is the moment when their eyes meet, everybody can see the love between them no matter how much they avoid having the conversation about them as a couple.

I tried, but it rang and rang, I called all night On a payphone, remember those from another life? If everything I meant to you You can't lick and seal then fold in two Then I've been so blind

-He’s reminding her of the better times in their relationship. He’s trying to bring her back to the beginning, a time when it was new and she will think of the relationship fondly. “Remember those, from another life?” Another life is the life she had with him, the beginning when everything was great between them. He realizes how much time has actually passed.

“If everything I meant to you, you can lick and seal then fold in two, then I’ve been so blind.” if I meant so very much to you, how can you just give up on us like that? Have I been so blind to see that I didn’t mean so much? Or did I? he was honesty from her.

Aw, aw take it all back, take your first, your last, your only Aw, aw take it all back, take it all back, everything you showed me Aw, aw this must be how it feels When the feeling goes on...

I think this means that he was her first love. “Take it all back, your first, your last, your only” means that she said he was her only true love. She wanted him forever as he did her. “Everything you showed me” must be the love she showed him, her life, letting him in. He still feels everything she showed him, he still wants to be everything she showed him and be in her life. He’s saying “If I meant this much to you, and you let me go so easily, it must have been a lie. Take back everything we did together because to you it meant nothing. To me it meant everything.” “This must be how it feels when the feeling goes on” are the feelings and how they feel when they aren’t reciprocated. This must be how it feels to not let go when the other person has.

I told you as I haven't, I never felt this way You said I have the shot that stops my clock Baby it's okay You said you never have regrets Jesus, is there someone yet who got that wish? Did you get yours, babe?

He’s never felt this way about anybody. Saying “I told you as I haven’t, I never felt this way” means he still hasn’t felt that way about anybody else since her. “You said you never have regrets, Jesus is there someone who got that wish?” He wonders if she regrets what happened between them although she says she doesn’t regret anything. “Does anyone ever not regret things they’ve done? No. Did you get your wish of never regretting anything? Cause I’m sure there are things you regret from this relationship that could have been done better or differently.”

Again, he reminds her to be honest with him about their current state of relationship and past relationship.

This song is reflective of my relationship with my ex. We talk and dance around what we know is true-we still care for another but can’t do anything about it. He’s going to be in a family member’s wedding party, as am I. I know that whenever our eyes meet they say things that we can’t say. It’s undeniable.

An error occured.