This seems to be about someone who refuses to acknowledge the world around them, instead resorting to the 'Goddidit' mentality.
He chastises her for self-imposed ignorance and the rebuttal of his friendship/attempts at helping her: "who then was your savior? Who then was your friend? Who is now committed to the present? Is it someone that exists?"
And then criticizes her ego: "what is life in God? A perfect vision of the self?" (As if God could be nothing other than what we wish we were)
The second verse seems to be a rebuttal of most Christians' arguments against atheists. What makes us who we are? Science doesn't attempt to answer that question, but that doesn't mean the religious are correct by default: "faith can't prove what science won't resolve."
I don't see this as an out and out attack on religion, though. He seems to be mad at the girl, but understands why she believes: "the river's long. it is cold. it chills the body but not the soul." Religion gets her through tough times, despite what he thinks of it.
This seems to be about someone who refuses to acknowledge the world around them, instead resorting to the 'Goddidit' mentality.
He chastises her for self-imposed ignorance and the rebuttal of his friendship/attempts at helping her: "who then was your savior? Who then was your friend? Who is now committed to the present? Is it someone that exists?"
And then criticizes her ego: "what is life in God? A perfect vision of the self?" (As if God could be nothing other than what we wish we were)
The second verse seems to be a rebuttal of most Christians' arguments against atheists. What makes us who we are? Science doesn't attempt to answer that question, but that doesn't mean the religious are correct by default: "faith can't prove what science won't resolve."
I don't see this as an out and out attack on religion, though. He seems to be mad at the girl, but understands why she believes: "the river's long. it is cold. it chills the body but not the soul." Religion gets her through tough times, despite what he thinks of it.