Lyric discussion by andrewxc 

Bill Pullman was first on Broadway in 2002, two years after the album came out, so no, it was not him.

Jeff Goldblum, however, was on Broadway in the 1970s and 1980s, but was not in many commercials.

Other likely candidates include Judd Hirsch, James Rebhorn, Randy Quaid, or Robert Loggia. I have not seen the "You don't need a medical" commercials, though.

An error occured.