Lyric discussion by ShatteringDesires 

ok, well this is what i got out of it.

Hands cover whispers of the lovers' fright

Me: "lover's being gagged from behind? hands from behind him covers his mouth." as jesterbunny said.

Fear-cloaked renditions of that autumn night Digging up rumours of the kids in the park What awful things happened in the dark? Me: kids hearing that somthing had happened at the park

Take, just one last dare Pretend you don't care Till twilight falls

Me: shes daring the lover to cheat on her and not care until he comes back

Wait, is someone else here? And I can't stop my tears I've never been so scared

Me: the girl he is cheating with thinks someone els is there and is scared

In the cellar buried 6 feet deep The lover's shaken from a dreamless sleep

Me: the lover wakes up in a cellar six feet under (duh) and has waken up from being knocked out

Nails clawing splinters from the ceiling and floor Shrieking like the witches til his stitches are sore

Me: he is digging at the walls trying to get out. the pain shreeks till his stitches (probebly got hit with somthing.) hurt.

Take, just one last dare Pretend you don't care Till twilight falls Wait, is someone else here? And I can't stop my tears I've never been so scared

Calling for the other, searching for her lover Secrets she discovers drain her face of color

Me: the woman he was cheaing with was looking for him,finds out what happens and is horrefied.

1.. 2.. 3.. 4 Underneath the cellar floor 5.. 6..7..8 Lover will suffocate

1.. 2.. 3.. 4 Underneath the cellar floor 5.. 6..7..8 Lover will suffocate

1.. 2.. 3.. 4 Underneath the cellar floor 5.. 6..7..8 Lover will suffocate

1.. 2.. 3.. 4 Underneath the cellar floor 5.. 6..7..8 Lover will suffocate

well, this is only my poinion. (sorry if my spelling is bad)

@ShatteringDesires I'm pretty sure the "cellar" is a coffin or some other wooden container. Otherwise he'd try to open the door, not dig at the walls/ceiling/floor (which are all made of wood, too - that would be weird if it was an actual cellar).

An error occured.