Lyric discussion by AvaAnthea 

This song annoys me.

Basically she's saying that at one time she and this guy had a good relationship. (Of course, this is only her POV). Now this guy is realising that she probably isn't good for him and he doesn't want to be with her anymore. His friends support his decision because they can see what he can't (which could possibly be that she's obsessive and potentially insane). Now she's being manipulative and saying,"We were so in love back then. Now you're listening to what they say. Don't go that way. Remember, remember December. Don't surrender." (Surrender to what? Good judgement?)

You can't build a relationship on memories. When it's time to move on, it's time to move on. I think the girl in this song needs to look at herself honestly, figure out why her relationship ended, and try to improve so the next guy doesn't leave her.

I don't like songs about on-off relationships where the girl is trying to convince the guy to give it another try. I'm sure anyone who has seen someone very hurt by an on-off relationship agrees with me.

An error occured.