My interpretation is that this most definitely is NOT an uplifting song (or song of hope). It is, indeed, a beautifully written and performed song...but it is a tragic song ("tragic" is probably too dramatic of a word).
I think it's a wake up for a dose of reality song. Despite the American Dream, we all are weary and battered...and unfulfilled. In each verse, the protagonist settles, or acquiesces, as he tells himself "it's alright, it's alright"...for we live so well so long...I'm just weary to my bones...you can't be forever blessed...
In each case, the protagonist tries to convince us or makes an excuse for accepting the disillusionment (that has existed since the Mayflower days...in other words, the "uncertain times" existed during the birth of the Nation, and will continue (forever?).
It's not that things are necessarily horrific; just a wake up call to that thing we call the American Dream. Simon's use of the melody, calling it the American Tune (as if it were an uplifting anthem, is brilliant). That's my interpretation. :)
@UWDawgfather - Yes, you are correct, it is "tragic" in the same sense that the Greeks intended for "tragedy" -- A fall from grace, generally due to hubris.
@UWDawgfather - Yes, you are correct, it is "tragic" in the same sense that the Greeks intended for "tragedy" -- A fall from grace, generally due to hubris.
Yes, I'd say that's the sound of our "American Tune."
Yes, I'd say that's the sound of our "American Tune."
My interpretation is that this most definitely is NOT an uplifting song (or song of hope). It is, indeed, a beautifully written and performed song...but it is a tragic song ("tragic" is probably too dramatic of a word).
I think it's a wake up for a dose of reality song. Despite the American Dream, we all are weary and battered...and unfulfilled. In each verse, the protagonist settles, or acquiesces, as he tells himself "it's alright, it's alright"...for we live so well so long...I'm just weary to my bones...you can't be forever blessed...
In each case, the protagonist tries to convince us or makes an excuse for accepting the disillusionment (that has existed since the Mayflower days...in other words, the "uncertain times" existed during the birth of the Nation, and will continue (forever?).
It's not that things are necessarily horrific; just a wake up call to that thing we call the American Dream. Simon's use of the melody, calling it the American Tune (as if it were an uplifting anthem, is brilliant). That's my interpretation. :)
@UWDawgfather - Yes, you are correct, it is "tragic" in the same sense that the Greeks intended for "tragedy" -- A fall from grace, generally due to hubris.
@UWDawgfather - Yes, you are correct, it is "tragic" in the same sense that the Greeks intended for "tragedy" -- A fall from grace, generally due to hubris.
Yes, I'd say that's the sound of our "American Tune."
Yes, I'd say that's the sound of our "American Tune."