Lyric discussion by Shanibandangle 

It is a heart-wrenching song. I can't wait to read the un-edited version of the song in the booklet though. In all honesty though, this is the only song I skip in the album! I know thats really harsh but I just don't click with Nicky's voice. I think it's scratchy and uncomfortable to listen to. They could of at least made it a duet.

I think it's brilliant that Nicky Wire sung it.

Yes, he has a terrible voice! We all know that, but him and Richey were best friends... I think James should be given a lot of credit for the effort put into this album, then just steps aside and let Nicky sing the most personal song on the album.

Beautiful song, I'm amazing Nicky got through it.

An error occured.