Lyric discussion by AdiAdi 

He says Please Stay Wendy because the song was originally titled "Peter Pan Complex". (Peter Pan never grew up, and this song is about Mark not growing up.) They later changed the name of the song to "What's My Age Again?" because they figured that a lot of people wouldn't understand it. Oh and before flaming my comment, look it up, you'll see that I'm right.

An error occured.