I am a new member, and it's so good to see and read so many fellow RUSH fans. Their respective musicianship, demeanor and intellectually progressive style is second to none, in my opinion, and makes them, again in my opinion, the best three piece rock band ever.
As a drummer, philosopher and appreciator of unique and interesting personalities, I have appreciated Neil Peart in various capacities for some time. As an undergraduate philosophy student (presently working on my Ph.D.) we were assigned in senior seminar to write about our favorite living philosopher. I turned in a twenty page treatise on Neil Peart and the look on my professors face was priceless. Without reading it, he handed it back and told me to grow up and do the assignment, stating "He's not even an academic. How could he be a philosopher?" (such attitudes are commonplace) I told him that if he didn't think differently after reading it I would quit school. He could tell I was serious. The next day, handing me a paper with the first letter of our alphabet scribed widely across the top, he asked me, embarrassed, if I would burn him a CD with "some of their stuff" :-)
As far as lyrical meaning, it is important to note that, while influenced by Twain, Rand and various others, he is (in his own words), "a disciple of no one." Through his lyrics we can piece together a personal philosophy, a proprietary blend, of anti-idealism/objectivism/individualism (Freewill, The Pass, TOM SAWYER, Show Don't Tell, Vital Signs, etc...), fatalism (Roll The Bones, a personal favorite), existentialism (again, Roll The Bones, Limelight, the title "All The World's A Stage") and several other philosophical influences.
Tom Sawyer (not Diane Sawyer, Ricky. hehe) is, in both the book and song, the personification of a sort or type of person, the sort of person breaking away from the status quo, exploring and, importantly, the sort who represents both a normative and actual shifting of the human paradigm in the direction of his (man's) rational evolution. This fits, to a greater or lesser extent, with Freud's idea that man evolves in such a way as to shed his dependence on ideals (religion, social norms) and replace that dependence with a greater implementation of reason (leading to self-reliance, a deeper self-awareness and sense of responsibility for ones own "destiny"). Tom Sawyer has thus been a different people at different transitional points in man's evolution (our history). "Todays" Tom Sawyer is exactly what the song says; a leader to the next step in realizing pure reason or rationality; the "space he invades," is his days work, to explore the unknown as progress towards truth; the "friction of the day," is the resistance he faces from both people's unwillingness to embrace change as well as the intellectual rigor of tackling what hasn't already been explored (the guy who cuts a path through the forest faces resistance from the brush leaving those who follow behind with little to do but be complacent and stagnate). He (TS) does all of this with a mind filled only by his own conclusions (i.e. "not for rent"), and via the power coming from honest intellectual reciprocity or dialectical process ("he gets high on you," "he gets by on you"). As far as "riding out the days events," the song is referring to fate controlling what life gives to us, even though it is our responsibility (and can be a point of pride if done well) to live our own life with what fate hands us. In RUSH's "Roll the Bones," Peart refers to the same notion, "we draw our own designs, but fortune has to make that frame."
The philosophical analysis could go on and on. Tom Sawyer is an intellectually (ideologically) dense song, as are many other of Peart's lyrics. It would take a while to thoroughly unpack them and I feel bad writing as much as I have. Sorry about that. I'm new, and haven't yet developed any restraint :-)
@roll_the_bones79 All three rush members have since recieved honorary PhDs, and given the amount of study it takes to do what they do, as well as the fact they are all published, it could be argued that they are, in fact, academics :-) Neil Peart is definitely a true intellectual and has studied philosophy in depth. So HAH! to your professor.
@roll_the_bones79 All three rush members have since recieved honorary PhDs, and given the amount of study it takes to do what they do, as well as the fact they are all published, it could be argued that they are, in fact, academics :-) Neil Peart is definitely a true intellectual and has studied philosophy in depth. So HAH! to your professor.
Going to university isn't the only way to get a quality and meaningful education.
Going to university isn't the only way to get a quality and meaningful education.
@roll_the_bones79 I deeply appreciate this, do you still have your paper? I’d love to read it and share with fans. Rest In Peace Neil Peart. The Professor.
@roll_the_bones79 I deeply appreciate this, do you still have your paper? I’d love to read it and share with fans. Rest In Peace Neil Peart. The Professor.
I am a new member, and it's so good to see and read so many fellow RUSH fans. Their respective musicianship, demeanor and intellectually progressive style is second to none, in my opinion, and makes them, again in my opinion, the best three piece rock band ever.
As a drummer, philosopher and appreciator of unique and interesting personalities, I have appreciated Neil Peart in various capacities for some time. As an undergraduate philosophy student (presently working on my Ph.D.) we were assigned in senior seminar to write about our favorite living philosopher. I turned in a twenty page treatise on Neil Peart and the look on my professors face was priceless. Without reading it, he handed it back and told me to grow up and do the assignment, stating "He's not even an academic. How could he be a philosopher?" (such attitudes are commonplace) I told him that if he didn't think differently after reading it I would quit school. He could tell I was serious. The next day, handing me a paper with the first letter of our alphabet scribed widely across the top, he asked me, embarrassed, if I would burn him a CD with "some of their stuff" :-)
As far as lyrical meaning, it is important to note that, while influenced by Twain, Rand and various others, he is (in his own words), "a disciple of no one." Through his lyrics we can piece together a personal philosophy, a proprietary blend, of anti-idealism/objectivism/individualism (Freewill, The Pass, TOM SAWYER, Show Don't Tell, Vital Signs, etc...), fatalism (Roll The Bones, a personal favorite), existentialism (again, Roll The Bones, Limelight, the title "All The World's A Stage") and several other philosophical influences.
Tom Sawyer (not Diane Sawyer, Ricky. hehe) is, in both the book and song, the personification of a sort or type of person, the sort of person breaking away from the status quo, exploring and, importantly, the sort who represents both a normative and actual shifting of the human paradigm in the direction of his (man's) rational evolution. This fits, to a greater or lesser extent, with Freud's idea that man evolves in such a way as to shed his dependence on ideals (religion, social norms) and replace that dependence with a greater implementation of reason (leading to self-reliance, a deeper self-awareness and sense of responsibility for ones own "destiny"). Tom Sawyer has thus been a different people at different transitional points in man's evolution (our history). "Todays" Tom Sawyer is exactly what the song says; a leader to the next step in realizing pure reason or rationality; the "space he invades," is his days work, to explore the unknown as progress towards truth; the "friction of the day," is the resistance he faces from both people's unwillingness to embrace change as well as the intellectual rigor of tackling what hasn't already been explored (the guy who cuts a path through the forest faces resistance from the brush leaving those who follow behind with little to do but be complacent and stagnate). He (TS) does all of this with a mind filled only by his own conclusions (i.e. "not for rent"), and via the power coming from honest intellectual reciprocity or dialectical process ("he gets high on you," "he gets by on you"). As far as "riding out the days events," the song is referring to fate controlling what life gives to us, even though it is our responsibility (and can be a point of pride if done well) to live our own life with what fate hands us. In RUSH's "Roll the Bones," Peart refers to the same notion, "we draw our own designs, but fortune has to make that frame."
The philosophical analysis could go on and on. Tom Sawyer is an intellectually (ideologically) dense song, as are many other of Peart's lyrics. It would take a while to thoroughly unpack them and I feel bad writing as much as I have. Sorry about that. I'm new, and haven't yet developed any restraint :-)
Thank you for this enlightening comment. I would love to read that treatise. Do you still have it? :)
Thank you for this enlightening comment. I would love to read that treatise. Do you still have it? :)
What a lovely story about the treatise :D
What a lovely story about the treatise :D
Except Pye Dubois wrote the lyrics for this (as he did for Between Sun and Moon)
Except Pye Dubois wrote the lyrics for this (as he did for Between Sun and Moon)
@roll_the_bones79 Fantastic job! Best post I've read all day!!
@roll_the_bones79 Fantastic job! Best post I've read all day!!
@roll_the_bones79 All three rush members have since recieved honorary PhDs, and given the amount of study it takes to do what they do, as well as the fact they are all published, it could be argued that they are, in fact, academics :-) Neil Peart is definitely a true intellectual and has studied philosophy in depth. So HAH! to your professor.
@roll_the_bones79 All three rush members have since recieved honorary PhDs, and given the amount of study it takes to do what they do, as well as the fact they are all published, it could be argued that they are, in fact, academics :-) Neil Peart is definitely a true intellectual and has studied philosophy in depth. So HAH! to your professor.
Going to university isn't the only way to get a quality and meaningful education.
Going to university isn't the only way to get a quality and meaningful education.
@neil,
@neil,
Going to university isn't the only way to get a quality and meaningful education.
Going to university isn't the only way to get a quality and meaningful education.
i agree....
i agree....
Well, we bursted out of class Had to get away from those fools We learned more from a three-minute record, baby Than we ever learned in school
Well, we bursted out of class Had to get away from those fools We learned more from a three-minute record, baby Than we ever learned in school
@roll_the_bones79 I deeply appreciate this, do you still have your paper? I’d love to read it and share with fans. Rest In Peace Neil Peart. The Professor.
@roll_the_bones79 I deeply appreciate this, do you still have your paper? I’d love to read it and share with fans. Rest In Peace Neil Peart. The Professor.