Lyric discussion by Guerillabaabaa 

I'm not sure, but I think it's this song.

I saw him live not so long ago, and he said that this song was a memory of his prom night. His town only had about half as many girls as guys, so when he went to the prom he had to "share" the date with his best friend, and they were kind of competing, and he got the second half of the night. Of course, that might be for a totally different song. The one above sounds pretty plausible

An error occured.