ehh screw you guys lol. when i first heard ryan adams' version of this song, i hated it, because it doesn't have the same singalong melody as the original, and that was the main reason i liked it. but after listening to it a few more times, it just made a lot more sense. the way ryan sings it makes the meaning of the song clearer than the oasis version. it makes it more beautiful and heartbreaking... i don't really think the oasis version has that same quality to it.
ehh screw you guys lol. when i first heard ryan adams' version of this song, i hated it, because it doesn't have the same singalong melody as the original, and that was the main reason i liked it. but after listening to it a few more times, it just made a lot more sense. the way ryan sings it makes the meaning of the song clearer than the oasis version. it makes it more beautiful and heartbreaking... i don't really think the oasis version has that same quality to it.