I feel it is an allusion to Plato's "Allegory of the Cave." While the ideas of commercialism (the people bow and pray to a neon god they made, the words of the prophets are written on the subway walls, etc) run throughout the poem, it also has to do with a frustration the narrator feels with humans in general. They are content to "hear without listening," not willing or interested in focusing on anyone or anything too intently. They are not willing to go beyond the superficial, but merely to accept the world around them, as no one "dares disturb the sounds of silence."
The allusion comes into play in the beginning, as the narrator has a revelation, a vision, that awakes him from this superficial, merely shadowed world. He rises, walks alone as the man in Plato's story did, and he sees the light. He tries to tempt others out of the cave of ignorance and look beyond teh surface of things, but his "words like silent raindrops" fall. His attempts are futile.
That's what I got out of the song, my two cents ^_^ An amazing song no matter how you interpret it!
OK brand new to this site, and I see that already I must complliment a previous Replier person. Love your interpretation and agree whole-heartedly! Better late than never only ELEVEN YEARS SINCE YOU POSTED IT come on people, appreciate the arts!
OK brand new to this site, and I see that already I must complliment a previous Replier person. Love your interpretation and agree whole-heartedly! Better late than never only ELEVEN YEARS SINCE YOU POSTED IT come on people, appreciate the arts!
@carabiner86@carabiner86
I completely agree with this interpretation. I however believe strongly that it is not commercialism they worship per se. It is the country/government they have built, thinking it is free, yet they are deceived by its brainwashing messages of patriotism. Like uncle Sam's "I want you" posts for instance. I say so because I heard/read somewhere that the song was written during the time of Vietnam War.
@carabiner86@carabiner86
I completely agree with this interpretation. I however believe strongly that it is not commercialism they worship per se. It is the country/government they have built, thinking it is free, yet they are deceived by its brainwashing messages of patriotism. Like uncle Sam's "I want you" posts for instance. I say so because I heard/read somewhere that the song was written during the time of Vietnam War.
I also think it could differ a bit more. The vision's source is spiritual, which still remains within the "dream" i.e world they live in. In comparison to the materialistic people who although still aware of or familiar with spirituality existance, insist on bowing to the made god, and refuse to join the speaker away from the deception.
I interpret this song slightly different.
I feel it is an allusion to Plato's "Allegory of the Cave." While the ideas of commercialism (the people bow and pray to a neon god they made, the words of the prophets are written on the subway walls, etc) run throughout the poem, it also has to do with a frustration the narrator feels with humans in general. They are content to "hear without listening," not willing or interested in focusing on anyone or anything too intently. They are not willing to go beyond the superficial, but merely to accept the world around them, as no one "dares disturb the sounds of silence."
The allusion comes into play in the beginning, as the narrator has a revelation, a vision, that awakes him from this superficial, merely shadowed world. He rises, walks alone as the man in Plato's story did, and he sees the light. He tries to tempt others out of the cave of ignorance and look beyond teh surface of things, but his "words like silent raindrops" fall. His attempts are futile.
That's what I got out of the song, my two cents ^_^ An amazing song no matter how you interpret it!
carabiner86's interpretation of the song is extremely well written and brilliant. Its on the last post on the first page.
carabiner86's interpretation of the song is extremely well written and brilliant. Its on the last post on the first page.
I like this interpretation. It seems that much literature may be described as 'a footnote to Plato'...
I like this interpretation. It seems that much literature may be described as 'a footnote to Plato'...
OK brand new to this site, and I see that already I must complliment a previous Replier person. Love your interpretation and agree whole-heartedly! Better late than never only ELEVEN YEARS SINCE YOU POSTED IT come on people, appreciate the arts!
OK brand new to this site, and I see that already I must complliment a previous Replier person. Love your interpretation and agree whole-heartedly! Better late than never only ELEVEN YEARS SINCE YOU POSTED IT come on people, appreciate the arts!
@carabiner86 @carabiner86 I completely agree with this interpretation. I however believe strongly that it is not commercialism they worship per se. It is the country/government they have built, thinking it is free, yet they are deceived by its brainwashing messages of patriotism. Like uncle Sam's "I want you" posts for instance. I say so because I heard/read somewhere that the song was written during the time of Vietnam War.
@carabiner86 @carabiner86 I completely agree with this interpretation. I however believe strongly that it is not commercialism they worship per se. It is the country/government they have built, thinking it is free, yet they are deceived by its brainwashing messages of patriotism. Like uncle Sam's "I want you" posts for instance. I say so because I heard/read somewhere that the song was written during the time of Vietnam War.
I also think it could differ a bit more. The vision's source is spiritual, which still remains within the "dream" i.e world they live in. In comparison to the materialistic people who although still aware of or familiar with spirituality existance, insist on bowing to the made god, and refuse to join the speaker away from the deception.
@carabiner86 I feel you hit right on. Makes perfect sense and truly relates. Makes the meaning most meaningful in my mind.
@carabiner86 I feel you hit right on. Makes perfect sense and truly relates. Makes the meaning most meaningful in my mind.
@Solo_guitarist I agree with you completely as well. Very well said both you and @carabiner86
@Solo_guitarist I agree with you completely as well. Very well said both you and @carabiner86