Even though it's not Roger singing, Hats Off To Roy Harper for doing a really great job with this. It still sounds like Pink floyd even w/o roger or dave singing. Duh, cuz of the instruments and lyrics but many times with different vocalists you can't tell.
Roger had a sore throat when they were planning on recording this song, so they got roy harper. i just wonder why dave couldn't sing it?
Dave said he wasn't "feeling up to it". He couldn't give that harsh cynical sound in his voice and Roy was recording in the next room and wanted to give it a try.
Dave said he wasn't "feeling up to it". He couldn't give that harsh cynical sound in his voice and Roy was recording in the next room and wanted to give it a try.
@AeroLed286 David refused to sing the song, according to him, "it did not look relaxed in his voice ampliture" or something. I think I read this in on one of the Pink Floyd books I own. By the way, they didn't get Roy Harper to sing it. He was recording his album in Abbey Road at the same week, he saw what was happening and offered to help. In exchange, Gilmour played guitar and sang for one of his songs in his album.
@AeroLed286 David refused to sing the song, according to him, "it did not look relaxed in his voice ampliture" or something. I think I read this in on one of the Pink Floyd books I own. By the way, they didn't get Roy Harper to sing it. He was recording his album in Abbey Road at the same week, he saw what was happening and offered to help. In exchange, Gilmour played guitar and sang for one of his songs in his album.
Even though it's not Roger singing, Hats Off To Roy Harper for doing a really great job with this. It still sounds like Pink floyd even w/o roger or dave singing. Duh, cuz of the instruments and lyrics but many times with different vocalists you can't tell.
Roger had a sore throat when they were planning on recording this song, so they got roy harper. i just wonder why dave couldn't sing it?
Dave said he wasn't "feeling up to it". He couldn't give that harsh cynical sound in his voice and Roy was recording in the next room and wanted to give it a try.
Dave said he wasn't "feeling up to it". He couldn't give that harsh cynical sound in his voice and Roy was recording in the next room and wanted to give it a try.
@AeroLed286 David refused to sing the song, according to him, "it did not look relaxed in his voice ampliture" or something. I think I read this in on one of the Pink Floyd books I own. By the way, they didn't get Roy Harper to sing it. He was recording his album in Abbey Road at the same week, he saw what was happening and offered to help. In exchange, Gilmour played guitar and sang for one of his songs in his album.
@AeroLed286 David refused to sing the song, according to him, "it did not look relaxed in his voice ampliture" or something. I think I read this in on one of the Pink Floyd books I own. By the way, they didn't get Roy Harper to sing it. He was recording his album in Abbey Road at the same week, he saw what was happening and offered to help. In exchange, Gilmour played guitar and sang for one of his songs in his album.
@AeroLed286 had no clue that featured roy harper
@AeroLed286 had no clue that featured roy harper