Shut out, pimpled and angry.
I quietly tied all my guts into knots.
gave up on trying to make them,
I figured it'd take them too long to look up and besides...

it was undeniably clear to me, I don't know why
when every other part of life seemed locked behind shutters
I knew the worthless dregs we've always been.

lucked out and found my favorite records
lying in wait at the Birmingham mall.
the songs that I heard,
the occasional book
were the only fun I ever took.
and I got on with making myself.

Yeah the trick is just making yourself
but when they're parking their cars on your chest
you've still got a view of the summer sky
to make it hurt twice when your restless body
caves to its whims
and suddenly struggles to take flight...

Three thousand miles north east
I left all my friends at the morning bus stop shaking their heads.
"what kind of life you dream of? you're allergic to love."
yes I know but I must say in my own defense
it's been undeniable dear to me, I don't know why
when every other part of life seemed locked behind shutters
I knew the worthless dregs we are,
the selfless, loving saints we are,
the melting, sliding dice we've always been.



Lyrics submitted by rudegirl, edited by Ryuhza

Track duration: 02:29


Know Your Onion! song meanings
Add your thoughts

77 Comments

sort form View by:
  • 0
    General Comment:An interesting note, when he sings this live, during the part that goes

    "The songs that I heard
    the occasional book
    were the only fun I ever took"

    He replaces the word "fun" with drugs. I always thought it was clever. The songs he heard and books he read were the only drugs he ever took...

    Well, at the time.
    Flag Ryuhzaon February 21, 2013   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:He's saying exactly what my bro told me!

    Know yourself first! He is struggling in life and looks up with music and doesn't care about love just yet , plus he's a shut out anyways so what's the point, right?
    Flag GrungyBeatleon July 26, 2012   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:"onion" is slang for your job or"life's work"...."know your onion".. i feel is writers comment about him knowing what he must do...i.e leave home and pursue his musical path
    Flag gackiswhackon November 29, 2010   Link
  • 0
    My Interpretation:I'm sure plenty of people have said similar stuff already, but what this song is about in my opinion is this:

    A young person is trying to figure out who they are. They do stuff to try to fit in, but still feel rejected. At some point they discover a bit of their true self and some happiness through some music and books, but still they try to be someone they're not even though it causes them emotional/physical pain. His or her friends realize that what this person is trying to do is not realistic, but the person still keeps on "making" his or herself. But when it comes down to it, he or she really does know just how fake people are.

    That's my take, anyways. :)

    To me, James Mercer is a lyrical genius. He's the only musician that I can say truly impresses me with their lyrics. Usually when it comes down to me liking music, it's not at all about the lyrics, but more about tune and melody and rhythm and feeling. But when it's James Mercer/The Shins, I know I'm gonna hear amazing lyrics too.
    Flag ILGBon November 15, 2010   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:Does anybody else think that the lines "but when they're parking their cars on your chest/ you've still got a view of the summer sky" are meant to be sarcastic? I mean, look at the lines that follow it: "to make it hurt twice when your restless body caves to its whims and suddenly struggles to take flight." I think it's saying that even when your being tormented/experiencing a tragic or depressing life, you're aware that there is happiness in the universe, which is a bad thing and only hurts you further ("makes it hurt twice") because you know you'll never be able to obtain it no matter how much you might want to ("suddenly struggles to take flight"). Anyway, that's just how I take its meaning.
    Flag shinsfan33on January 24, 2010   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:I think this song is about a socially awkward teenager, for, whatever reason, has commitment issues. Sounds prototypical, but no one mentioned it yet.

    Shut out, pimpled and angry.
    I quietly tied all my guts into knots.
    Gave up on trying to make them,
    I figured it'd take them too long to look up and besides...
    -The first line is a pretty quick description of out main character. He's obviously upset about something, and from the second lines, we can assume he is trying to make a team or club. 'Trying to make them'? Like 'make the team'? But because he is such an awkward, self conscious person, he decides it would take to long for them (as in maybe the coach or the like) to even acknowledge he was there. And even then it's unlikely he'd make it, so he decides to not even trying or 'gave up on trying to make them'.

    It was undeniably clear to me I don't know why
    When every other part of life seemed locked behind shutters
    I knew what worthless dregs we all are then.
    -He then realizes that when every other aspect of your life is inside your house alone, 'locked behind shutters', we become worthless. So, giving up on making whatever team has only added to his feelings of insecurity and isolation.

    lucked out and found my favorite records
    lying in wait at the birmingham mall.
    the songs the i heard,
    the occasional book
    were the only fun I ever took.
    and I got on with making myself.
    the trick is just making yourself.
    -Since our main character doesn't have a club or team, no hobbies, and apparently no friends, he sits around listening to music and reading. This is his entire life, he doesn't go on dates or to parties, 'were the only fun I ever took'. He 'got on with making [himself]', in other words, he spent his days thinking about who he was as a person alone. He is trying to figure out who he is. To 'make' his own identity.

    but when they're parking their cars on your chest
    you've still got a view of the summer sky
    to make it hurt twice when your restless body
    caves to its whims
    and suddenly struggles to take flight...
    -Despite trying to 'find himself', people are obviously crushing him or 'parking cars on your chest'. He tries to find a positive to it, and then realizes that when you try and run away from your problems, it only ends up hurting more because you'll have wished you've done something. The 'restless body caving into it's whims' is a young man becoming to scared to confront whatever problem he has socially and is just leaving to be by himself, to 'take flight'.

    three thousand miles north east
    i left all my friends at the morning bus stop shaking their heads.
    "what kind of life you dream of? you're allergic to love."
    -This goes in with the previous lines. This boy has abandoned his friends by themselves because he got upset with something and wasn't emotionally mature enough to deal with it. Even they start to realize that he needs to learn to get along with people, and say that he's 'allergic to love'. That line pretty much means this kid is scared to form a meaningful relationship, if you view love in a non-romantic way.

    yes i know but i must say in my own defense
    it's been undeniable dear to me, i don't know why
    when every other part of life seemed locked behind shutters
    i knew the worthless dregs we are,
    the selfless, loving saints we are,
    the melting, sliding dice we've always been.
    -Note how the singer sings "what kind of life you dream of? you're allergic to love", he's making his voice higher pitched to make fun or patronize these friends. This kid is really offended by their analysis, but can't express it. So he retaliates 'I must say in my own defense' (These are friends, you don't defend yourself from friends). He goes on to say that being a bit of a loner has allowed him to see people for who they really are. And that while he may be socially inept, not fit in, and not have friends, the other kids have phony relationships. And he's saying it's the same as being alone is the same as having a 'fake' relationship.

    Regardless, this song is definitely about self discovery, like Greyshoes said. The masturbation idea hasn't really appealed to me because so many of the lyrics detract from that idea.
    Flag fuzzyforeveron December 22, 2009   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:this was the first shin's song i heard. and its probably my favorite
    Flag sooperooperdooperon August 04, 2009   Link
  • +1
    General Comment:I love the little voice "What kind of life you dream of? you're allergic to love" :)
    Flag brisweeton June 23, 2009   Link
  • +1
    General Comment:"Know your Onion!"
    shut out, pimpled and angry.
    i quietly tied all my guts into knots.
    gave up on trying to make them,
    i figured it'd take them too long to look up and besides...
    [This is Mercer describing his teenage years: introverted, frustrated, and discovering his own intelligence. The first real chapter of his life, he is rejected and ridiculed by his peers for being himself. He probably tried to convince everyone that there were more important things in life, but he eventually gave up because it only got him in more trouble.]

    it was undeniably clear to me, i don't know why
    when every other part of life seemed locked behind shutters
    i knew what worthless dregs we've always been
    [At some point in his life, he had an epiphany for whatever reason. It seemed, to Mercer, that most kids and conforming teenagers have a pretty worthless existance because they can't see any of the valuable parts of life (they're all "locked behind shutters"). All they can see is popularity and apperances and petty nonsense.]

    lucked out and found my favorite records
    lying in wait at the birmingham mall.
    the songs the i heard,
    the occasional book
    were the only fun i ever took.
    and i got on with making myself.
    the trick is just making yourself.
    [I can relate to this because I remember the first time I bought my first CD and realized how much music could help me. Mercer catches a break from the frustration of school when he starts going to the mall and finding his interests. He slowly begins to get an idea of what lies behind the shutters as he reads books and listens to records, so he decides to keep heading in that direction and "making himself" into the person he wants to be: a musician. "The trick", he says, "is forcing yourself to put up with the BS in the meantime".]

    but when they're parking their cars on your chest
    you've still got a view of the summer sky
    to make it hurt twice when your restless body
    caves to its whims
    and suddenly struggles to take flight...

    [Mercer is now talking directly to the listener about the difficulties of trying to fulfill your dreams. He's saying that whenever life gets hard and you're discouraged and nobody believes in you, just keep your eye on your dreams and take pride in doing so. This section is one of of Mercer's infamous "epitaphs" , it reminds the listener that there will always be setbacks, but that they should never give up.]

    three thousand miles north east
    i left all my friends at the morning bus stop shaking their heads.
    "what kind of life you dream of? you're allergic to love."
    yes i know but i must say in my own defense

    [He finally understands what it is he needs to do to fulfill his dreams, so he packs his things and moves far away from his hometown and his past life. His friends think he's crazy and he'll never make it work, but he says that it's something he just has to do and he doesn't care if it works or not]

    it's been undeniable dear to me, i don't know why
    when every other part of life seemed locked behind shutters
    i knew the worthless dregs we are,
    the selfless, loving saints we are,
    the melting, sliding dice we've always been.

    [It's incredibly important to him to find himself, though he has no idea why. When everything else in his life seemed out of reach and he finally grew up a little, he realized how worthless, how selfless, how loving, and how multi-faceted we are as human beings. Like the myriad layers of an onion.]
    Flagged rebelquietlyon March 31, 2009   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:I think this song is about people, in general...parts of it are, anyway. The last three lines, which seem contradictory, feel to me like they're sort of sad but loving at the same time over the nature of people. Also there are the lines in the middle, the "parking their cars" stanza...that also seems to be talking about human struggles and desires. It's got lots of "we" and "us," and in songs that usually either means a pair of lovers, which I don't think this is, or humanity. It's almost like he's saying he's too caught up in life, and how different and complicated people are, to stop for love, while at the same time he's estranged from it. (Left his friends, feels shut out and ignored, angry.) Perhaps its about his change from his original pessimistic view of people to realizing that we are all fundamentally the same, in that we are imperfect.... :)
    Flag Quazalleon March 26, 2009   Link

Add your thoughts

Log in now to tell us what you think this song means.

Don’t have an account? Create an account with SongMeanings to post comments, submit lyrics, and more. It’s super easy, we promise!

Back to top
explain