cattail down,
the morning rail yard whistle blows.
cattail down,
our boxcar bound for... no one knows.
after every hidden seed out
from it covering has been free,
and every book has been discarded from the bookshelf.
cattail down,
and the forgetting of myself.

cattail down,
replace the feathers in our vests.
cattail down,
surround the ivy
thats gone to poison in my chest.
"the parachute broke loose,"
cried the goose with misplaced
but understandable concern
for his little brother's mental health.
his happy little brother,
and the forgetting of himself.

cattail down,
around the bulrush, the pollen shed.
cattail down,
to dress my wounds,
it left a bee sting in their stead.

half an acre thoughts from out my head.

headed east out of st. paul,
we stopped for water.
rested in the cemetery,
watched the mississippi.
running out of food stamps,
found a bag along the footpath
off highway 61 filled with
what looked like marijuana.
(don't worry mom, we left it there)

hopped a grainrail out of pig's eye
toward milwaukee, a deer
between the tower and the tracks,
saw right through us.
said, "you don't know where you came from,
you don't know where you're going,
you think you're you-
you don't know who you are,
you're not you.
you're everyone else."

you're everyone else.



Lyrics submitted by aaron_kaump

Track duration: 03:47


Cattail Down song meanings
Add your thoughts

17 Comments

sort form View by:
  • 0
    General Comment:last verse reminds me of the scene in stand by me with the deer. I love it.
    Flag LLAFoxon December 09, 2010   Link
  • 0
    My Interpretation:Imagine yourself as a pillow and think about Locke's Tabula Rasa theory, then listen to this again.

    At the same time, the giving up everything for Christ idea applies, or any other spiritual sentiment which disregards material gain for identity, love of all beings, true happiness, etc (which Weiss writes about a lot).

    It works on many levels because Aaron Weiss is brilliant and knows how to reach two audiences equally.
    Flag rocknrollgirl47on June 22, 2010   Link
  • +4
    General Comment:i just saw the Weiss Family and Friends in Buffalo, NY. After the show, i asked Aaron what they say in the middle of this song, and he told me it is "Half an acre thoughts from out my head!" Apparently, his ex-fiancee is engaged to a new person and they live on a half-acre farm. This was his way of putting her completely out of his mind and being happy for her new life. He also said that this is the only line on this album dealing with her after writing a lot about her in the past. Just wanted to let everyone know.
    Flag easiersungthansaidon August 18, 2009   Link
  • +1
    General Comment:You're not you
    You're everyone else
    You're everyone else
    You're everyone else
    You're everyone else
    You're everyone else
    Flag HWOntoFireon August 12, 2009   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:I think the idea that the train-hopping references are Weiss romanticizing the band's touring is interesting but, at the same time, even mewithoutYou has to take a break from touring and I would fully expect train-hopping to be one of Aaron Weiss' favorite things to do with his free time. All those references could be quite literal.

    Also, as far as that line that the whole band sings, I have no idea what it is either but I keep singing it to myself as "I've been leaking thoughts from out my head" which is ridiculous, I know, but made sense to me if only because in "Fig With a Bellyache" he says, "Got a heck of a lot to learn about remaining taciturn." Maybe he feels like he speaks too much without thinking first.
    Flag teajamson July 05, 2009   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:"the parachute broke loose,"
    cried the goose with misplaced
    but understandable concern
    for his little brother's mental health.
    his happy little brother,
    and the forgetting of himself.

    When I read this verse I got this out of it:

    -"the parachute broke loose,"
    I think this means he took a leap of faith. It could refer to when Aaron started living with the simple way. I think it just means totally relying on God.

    -cried the goose with misplaced
    but understandable concern
    for his little brother's mental health.
    In "American Christianity" a lot of people will see a true act of faith as something dangerous or suprising. It is understandable that his older brother (or whoever it refers to) would have concern for Aaron giving up all of his own understanding/desires and leaning all on faith. Yet at the same time it is misplaced because he is confident that God will provide.

    his happy little brother,
    and the forgetting of himself.
    And this just sums it all up showing that by forgetting himself and relying all on God he has found true happiness



    Flag thrice07on July 01, 2009   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:I talked to Aaron for a long time after mwY played in Orlando and he mentioned the duality of the self at one point, quoting directly from the "you're everyone else" part of this song. Judging from that, I think he's voicing his very deeply held belief that God is in all people and things and that we're being rather short-sighted in always attempting to divide ourselves and be separate from one another. That also harkens back to all the spider songs on Brother, Sister ("Yellow spider, yellow leaf confirms my deepest held belief," et cetera). I don't know, just an idea. Regardless, excellent record.
    Flag yourmercurymouthon June 13, 2009   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:Regarding the line "Cattail down, replace the feathers in our vest," I just found an article in a greenie magazine that brought up the idea of replacing goose down with cattail down.

    motherearthnews.com/Modern-Homesteading/1980-07-01/…

    Of course, what that has to do with the rest of the song is still kind of an enigma.
    Flag mirrizinon June 08, 2009   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:i found this today (by rumi, of course!)

    “when you are with everyone but me, you’re with no one.
    when you are with no one but me, you’re with everyone.
    instead of being so bound up with everyone, be everyone.
    when you become that many, you’re nothing. empty.”

    - rumi

    it sounds similar, sounds applicable to the song. i think it also helps it make sense.
    Flag harloton May 27, 2009   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:At least the latter half of this song is about being lost. I think he is speaking on behalf of himself and the band. They must feel very lost in their lifestyle of touring and traveling without certainties, leaving behind everything at times to do what they feel is right for them. The geographic references like "St. Paul," "Mississippi," "Highway 61," "Milwaukee," etc, definitely suggest the touring. The last two verses really illustrate this sequence of wandering: "You don't know where you came from, you don't know where you're going." I think the "boxcar" in these lyrics refers to his tour bus, and that's just his way of romanticizing his story with the feel of antiquity.

    "after every hidden seed out
    from it covering has been free,
    and every book has been discarded from the bookshelf.
    cattail down,
    and the forgetting of myself."

    I feel like he's saying that only after he's completely stripped himself of his superficial identity and maybe every obligation or expectation he'd had in his life (uncovering the seeds), as well as everything that lies in his past (discarding the books), only then is he free to become himself. Forgetting himself seems to be a healthy practice in finding happiness.

    "you don't know where you came from,
    you don't know where you're going,
    you think you're you-
    you don't know who you are,
    you're not you.
    you're everyone else."

    I think these lyrics are applicable to anyone who feels lost, but perhaps Aaron struggles with his identity also. He may be trying to discard his role that's been ascribed to him as this great figure who preaches his word of God (he writes about this problem in January 1979 as well, with his "grasshopper king" metaphor), and perhaps he's saying that he's nothing special. Maybe it came to him when he saw that deer, a pure creature of God, telling him that he's nothing, he's a regular person, just like everyone else.

    I could be way off.
    Flag brightasthesunon May 26, 2009   Link

Add your thoughts

Log in now to tell us what you think this song means.

Don’t have an account? Create an account with SongMeanings to post comments, submit lyrics, and more. It’s super easy, we promise!

Back to top
explain