The DA is dressed to the nines
In the mirror, he practices all his lines
To his closing argument, 12 hearts beat in favour
I'm guessing he read the morning paper
The headline reads "The Man Hangs"
But the jury doesn't

And everyone's looking for relief
United States versus disbelief
Mothers cast tears on both sides of the aisle
Clear your throat and face the world
The verdict falls like bachelors for bad luck girls
Only breathing with the aid of denial

Case open, and case shut
But you could pay to close it like a casket
Baby boy can't lift his headache head
Isn't it tragic?

He glances at his peers sitting 7 to 12
Stacked on 1 to 6
The gallery is hushed

Boys in three pieces dream of grandstanding and bravado
The city sleeps in a cell
Notwithstanding what we all know
They hang on a rope or bated breath
Whichever you prefer

And everyone's looking for relief
A bidding war for an old flame's grief
The cause, the kid,
[the cuff, the charm
and the curse]

There's not a word that can make you comprehend
Too well dressed for the witness stand
The press prays for whichever headline's worse

Case open, and case shut
But you could pay to close it like a casket
Baby boy can't lift his headache head
Isn't it tragic?

Fresh pressed suit and tie
Unimpressed birds sing and die
Can talk my way out of anything
The foreman reads the verdict:
"In the above entitled actions, we find the defendent,
Guilty, guilty, guilty"

Case open, and case shut
But you could pay to close it like a casket
Baby boy can't lift his headache head
Isn't it tragic?

Case open, case shut
But you could pay to close it like a casket
Baby boy can't lift his headache head
Isn't it tragic?



Lyrics submitted by shrodes, edited by Mellow_Harsher

Track duration: 03:42


You're Crashing, but You're No Wave song meanings
Add your thoughts

73 Comments

sort form View by:
  • 0
    General Comment:One thing a lot of you are missing is the emphasis on money all throughout the song. Or perhaps it doesn't matter.
    Flag Nshane100on March 10, 2013   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:Definitely not about this, but the song makes me think of the Pee-wee Herman case in 1991. Could be though, because PW had a huge influence on people around the age of FOB's band members.

    "I'm guessing he read the morning paper
    The headline reads 'The Man Hangs'"
    (Possibly in reference to a very famous article regarding the case, stating Reubens' alter-ego Pee-wee Herman is dead.)

    "The verdict falls like bachelors for bad luck girls"
    (He got caught for indecent exposure in a adult theater.)

    Case open, and case shut
    "But you could pay to close it like a casket"
    (He pleaded no contest, $75 dollar fine to "close it like a casket" though he maintained his innocence, no longer wanted to go through the trial.)
    "Baby boy can't lift his headache head"
    (Pee-wee Herman, perceived as innocent and childlike... which is why people had such a hard time accepting this case.)
    Isn't it tragic?

    "Boys in three pieces dream of grandstanding and bravado"
    (Could refer to those who caught him, witnesses, or comedic imitators of PW.)

    "Fresh pressed suit and tie" (Though it's what all men wear in court, it's what Pee-wee wore all the time.)
    "Unimpressed birds sing and die" (Juxtaposition to Pee-wee's innocent world, birds singing, etc.)

    "The cause, the kid, the cuff, the charm, and the curse." (Having fame and then losing it, speaks for itself.)
    Flag misguidedmelodyon April 03, 2012   Link
  • 0
    My Interpretation:Taking all literal meaning aside, I believe this song is a metaphor for judgement. Notice how the audience is never aware of the defendant's actions or what he did to be found guilty. I think this is because it's a societal reference about how regardless of our actions, we will always be judged and we will always be found guilty. The line "United States vs. disbelief," I believe is to tell the audience that it's me against the world, whether you want to believe it or not.
    Flag Vincereon March 30, 2012   Link
  • 0
    Song Meaning:I'm sure it's either an '80s reference but it blatantly talks about the affects of trials on everyone in them.
    Flag glowinthedark47on January 14, 2011   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:reminds me of Build God by Panic! because of the lawyer but also because these lyrics seem to be colloquials saying that I still don't know the meaning of much like the ones in Build God
    Flag sergiolealon January 28, 2010   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:This is my favorite Fall Out Boy song. I really like this song because its different. Some lyrics are missing to this song. My favorite lines are, Boys in three pieces dream of grandstanding and bravado,Too well dressed for the witness stand, and Can talk my way out of anything.


    Flag danceallnighton January 05, 2010   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:This is most definitely one of my favorites by Fall Out Boy, no question about it. Probably because I really love songs that tell stories like this.

    This song really tells about the tension in a serious court case. It sounds to me like a young boy has thrown his life away by committing a crime and getting caught. He tries to save his life by lying his crime away ("Only breathing with the aid of denial"). But in the end, the jury sees through it and he's found guilty.
    Flag cassiexlynnon February 21, 2009   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:This song has to deal with them arson trail of Fred Hampton.
    All the lyrics have to deal with the trail and jury. He was charged with little evidince, but was then paroled.
    Flag tacomanon September 05, 2008   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:Wasn't Fred Hampton from Chicago?
    Flag MikeyyNastyon January 20, 2008   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:I'm almost a hundred percent certain it was based on To Kill A Mockingbird; saw that while I was going through the novel last night. Tom Robbins, an American of African ancestry, was the accused, who was later on found guilty. It had a tragic ending; he, who, in the novel, is symbolized by the mockingbird (according to Atticus Finch, his lawyer--I believe he is also the DA--it is a sin to kill a mockingbird, for they are innocent creatures indeed--all they do is sing, or do their best to please people). This idea is reflected in the line: "Unimpressed birds sing and die." True, both he and Atticus were unable to talk their way out of the case; as a result he was put in prison, tried to escape and was mercilessly killed. This is the said "tragic ending." He was helpless as a "baby boy," discriminated harshly by people surrounding him; thus he could not lift his head and face everything with confidence, for social restrictions were holding him back. Listen to this song once more, best while reading the book (especially when you get to the part about the court trials), and you'll know.
    Flag VintageRockstaron November 28, 2007   Link

Add your thoughts

Log in now to tell us what you think this song means.

Don’t have an account? Create an account with SongMeanings to post comments, submit lyrics, and more. It’s super easy, we promise!

Back to top
explain