We found your name across the chapel door
Carved in cursive with a table fork
Muddy hymnals
And some bootmarks where you'd been

The shaking preacher told the captain's man
The righteous suffer in a fallen land
And pulled the shade
To keep the crowd from peeking in

We found your children by the tavern door
With wooden buttons and an apple core
Playing house
And telling everyone you'd drowned

The begging choir told the captain's man
We all assume the worst the best we can
And for a round or two
They'd gladly track you down

We found you sleeping by your lover's stone
A ream of paper and a telephone
A broken bow
Across a long lost violin

Your lover's angel told the captain's man
It never ends the way we had it planned
And kissed her palm
And placed it on your dreaming head



Lyrics submitted by slickboot

Track duration: 02:44


Muddy Hymnal song meanings
Add your thoughts

18 Comments

sort form View by:
  • 0
    My Interpretation:Maybe its because of the current state of my life but I interpret this song a little different then everyone else.

    This song to me is about 3 people. The singer, a woman, and the past love(who has died).

    "Found your name across the chapel door carved in cursive with a table fork"
    The singer who is the current lover of the woman comes to the funeral. He sees the name she was suppose to have after marrying the past love. The description its carved in cursive with a table fork means it took a long time. Something someone would have to take time to do. It was suppose to be her name.

    "Found your children by the tavern door"
    Once again these were the children she was suppose to have. The past lover married someone else.

    "Found you sleeping by your lover's stone, a ream of paper and a telephone, a broken bow across a long lost violin."
    He finds her at the grave. The ream of paper is the address for the funeral, whilst the telephone is the call she got informing her of the lover's passing. A broken bow across a violin is a metaphor for them being meant to be together or at least she thought but now he's gone/broken.

    "Your lover's angel told the captain's man, it never ends the way we had it planned, kissed your palm and placed it on your dreaming head"
    This is either what she feels happened or what she tells herself. If her lover could speak to her he would tell her he loved her things just don't work out sometimes. Right person, wrong time that kind of thing.

    Thats just my dumb interpretation. Alot of Beam's music that deal with love seem to have the same theme of being plagued with the regret of letting that one get away. Look at "Bird Stealing Bread", "Promising Light", "Sixteen Maybe Less" and "Passing Afternoon"
    Flag penguin82on April 11, 2012   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:Isn't it "The righteous suffer and the falling land?" Seems to make more sense, especially given the religious overtones of the song. I&W uses a lot of Christian imagery in his music. Not necessarily a Christina himself, perhaps a student of early German Idealism/Romanticism.
    Flag El_Loboon February 10, 2012   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:I see no evidence of a murder... if there were one I think Beam would have left us a clearer hint based on what he does decide to tell us.

    Table forks are not found in chapels, nor would someone use one for a premeditated crime of vandalism. It suggests an item grabbed in a moment of anger and pain and used in a relatively spontaneous act. "Some bootmarks" don't suggest a lot of activity to me either, rather an attempt at prayer.

    The shaking preacher, his actions, and use of the word "righteous" and "fallen land" suggest to me that he is referring to an indignity (vandalizing the church and perhaps causing a small commotion inside) that he himself suffered, at the hands of someone who is simply a member of a community who doesn't care much for the church and its traditions, rather than someone who has committed a crime against someone else.

    I think "you" is a man, friends with the singer, who lost a lover in a tragedy. He first neglects his kids out of agony and desolation, to the point where they have nothing and have essentially given up on him as someone who looks after him. He ends up down at the tavern where he proceeds to go on a binge. In a fit of drunken rage and anger, he grabs a fork off the tavern table and rushes out stumbling off to who knows where. The children, sometime later, almost playfully say he's drowned. I imagine that the town is near a river and its been raining, and when people disappear off for a while in places like that people say, oh he must have gone off and drowned. The children really mean, who knows where the hell that train wreck went off to. (if you walk into a dive bar and ask where one of the missing and frequently drunk and annoying regulars is, you often get a similar response from his friends). In actuality he ran to the chapel and defaced it in anger at God for taking his lover, and then broke down and prayed, finally stumbling off to the grave of his lover where he passes out. The imagery of the phone, paper, and violin are I think, as virtuallypainless points out, poetic elements added to the story to express an inability and frustration with communicating to his lover. The captain is the police captain, language consistent with this old fashioned English(?) vocabulary like tavern and chapel, who sends his man to inquire about the issue. He goes round the chapel, and the tavern, where he finds a bunch of drunken beggars who as gossips love to exaggerate stories, and as drunks offer to go find the missing man for a drink. He, and the singer, finally finds the man sleeping at the grave. The angel is in my opinion not the lover, but a benevolent, all-knowing, heavenly onlooker who closes the chapter with a tender expression of love, care, pity, and beauty, as the man has found his lover in his dreams.

    This beautiful song has a tone which is not angry, nor is it judgmental. The man is somebody we can identify with, at least better than the other characters. It is sad, and sympathetic. At least that's my take.
    Flag matthewevanon June 22, 2009   Link
  • 0
    My Interpretation:We found you sleeping by your lover's stone
    A ream of paper and a telephone
    -- A ream of paper is useless without a typewriter. A telephone is useless without a cord, which it likely doesn't have out in the middle of a cemetery.

    A broken bow across a long lost violin
    -- A broken bow isn't going to make any music on a violin that isn't even there.

    Written word, spoken word, and music are all forms of communication. Sam has so poignantly expressed a complete inability to communicate here, despite the subject's desperate desire to bridge the gap between the living and the dead to be closer with his lost love.

    I see this song as a story, and I personally don't care if the lover was the captain's wife, the captain's fiancee, or the subject's wife. It's beautiful. This song is simple yet cryptic and incredibly beautiful. One of the songs that drew me in to Iron & Wine.
    Flag virtuallypainlesson April 29, 2009   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:this song is so beautiful; sam beam's voice is pure.
    Flag grapeyduckling12on August 28, 2008   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:Here's my storyline:
    1. Man loses his wife sometime fairly recently. (The kids aren't grown up yet, but the wife has been buried already, so I don't think it's a murder).

    2. He gets angry one night and wants to drown himself. He drops the kids off at the tavern, and has them tell everyone that he's drowned.

    3. He heads off to the river, where he tries to drown himself, but something happens after he's in the water. Maybe he panics, or realizes the value of life, or his wife's angel stops him.

    4. In frustration, he tromps off to the church in his muddy boots, where he creates a huge mess, kicking hymnals around, and leaving mud prints everywhere.

    5. For some reason he wants to vandalize the church, but wants everyone to know it was him. He grabs the only thing nearby (a table fork) and carves his name above the door. Maybe he feels forgotten in his misery, and is crying out for attention.

    6. -- The rest is pretty much what everyone else has said, except for the murder bit.
    Flag krackerdogon June 10, 2008   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:I do like this 'murder' idea, and I think it's probably the most accurate. The way always took it, though, was that a man had lost his wife and 'gone off the rails', carving his name into the church and then leaving his children by the tavern, telling them he was going to drown himself, before stumbling to his wife's grave and crying himself to sleep. Meanwhile, the people in the village (I'm assuming it's a village) gather up a search party to look for the missing man, with the "begging choir" literally being a group of beggars outside the tavern. They find him by the grave, and the wife's angel appears to the search party, and explains to the captain's man why the husband has done this.

    that's my take anyway :)
    Flag ejejejon April 27, 2008   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:Close, but the murder happened at the church. That's why the crowd was gathered there. That's why the preacher was shaking and pulling the shade. The sleeping man at the grave ("you") is the Captain's wife's lover. The captain's man was hired to kill them both. He killed the wife first, and then was still searching for the man even after she had been buried. The lover "you" must have been hiding out during the funeral, but then eventually went to see his lover(the captain's wife)'s grave in drunken sorrow. We do not know whether the group of people that eventually found him (you) sleeping at the grave were hired by the captain's man, or if they (we) were friends that heard about the manhunt and went to find him (you) first. Hopefully it was the latter, and there might be some evidence for this in the fact that the angel tells the captain's man that, "it never ends the way we had it planned." Also, the beggar's choir which may have been hired to track him (you) down, is referred to as being separate from the "we" that eventually found him...and the lover's angel kissing her palm and placing it on his dreaming head may mean that she is watching over him and used her angel powers to make sure that the right group of people found him (you) first...or maybe they (we) found him (you) right as the captain's man was about to kill him (you), enabling the conversation between the wife/lover's angel and the Captain's man to take place as he was being handcuffed by the police....Maybe that's who the "we" is ...the police?

    Also, manuel, please do not call other people's comments stupid...even if you're going to say, "no offense" afterward. There are many layers of meaning to this cryptically worded song and every interpretation on here, including your own, adds legitimate insight into what is being said.
    Flag dustybasicson March 01, 2008   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:The more stupid comments are the most eager to be read.......but I tell you now...no offense.....we all have different eyes..............the captain's man kills his wife because she had a Lover......he killed her at her lover's grave...captain's men have a tendency to be violent.....now try listening to the song with this Idea in mind........does it paint a better picture? cuz if it does.,,,,,,,,,that's how it should be.,,,,..........my respect for all Iron & Wine fans,,,..............We truly are listeners of the most beaufitul true music........
    Flag manuelturcioson December 26, 2007   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:the woman, I meant to say, is the long-lost violin.
    Flag kylesseyon July 27, 2007   Link

Add your thoughts

Log in now to tell us what you think this song means.

Don’t have an account? Create an account with SongMeanings to post comments, submit lyrics, and more. It’s super easy, we promise!

Back to top
explain