Elope with me, Miss Private, and we’ll sail around the world
I will be your Ferdinand and you my wayward girl
How many nights of talking in hotel rooms can you take?
How many nights of limping around on pagan holidays?
Oh, elope with me in private and we’ll set something ablaze
A trail for the devil to erase

San Francisco’s calling us, the Giants and Mets will play
Piazza, New York catcher, are you straight or are you gay?
We hung about the stadium, we’ve got no place to stay
We hung about the Tenderloin and tenderly you tell
About the saddest book you ever read, it always makes you cry
The statue’s crying too and well he may

I love you, I’ve a drowning grip on your adoring face
I love you, my responsibility has found a place
Beside you and strong warnings in the guise of gentle words
Come wave upon me from the family wider net absurd
“You’ll take care of her, I know it, you will do a better job”
Maybe, but not what she deserves

Elope with me, Miss Private, and we’ll drink ourselves awake
We’ll taste the coffee houses and award certificates
A privy seal to keep the feel of 1960s style
We’ll comment on the decor and we’ll help the passer by
And at dusk when work is over we’ll continue the debate
In a borrowed bedroom virginal and spare

The catcher hits for .318 and catches every day
The pitcher puts religion first and rests on holidays
He goes into cathedrals and lies prostrate on the floor
He knows the drink affects his speed, he’s praying for
a doorway
Back into the life he wants and the confession of the bench
Life outside the diamond is a wrench

I wish that you were here with me to pass the dull weekend
I know it wouldn’t come to love, my heroine pretend
A lady stepping from the songs we love until this day
You’d settle for an epitaph like “Walk Away, Renee”
The sun upon the roof in winter will draw you out like
a flower
Meet you at the statue in an hour
Meet you at the statue in an hour



Lyrics submitted by ReActor, edited by CaptainOAP

Track duration: 03:03


Piazza, New York Catcher song meanings
Add your thoughts

96 Comments

sort form View by:
  • +3
    My Interpretation:I think many people have correct interpretations, especially pertaining to the baseball and homosexual references. I do, however, think many people are missing the mark.

    The male in this song is obviously gay. I think many people are overlooking the female's sexuality. For starters, he calls her his "wayward girl". While this can have several meanings, especially as they pertain to sailing across the world, I believe it is also a reference to her ambiguous, perhaps bisexuality. She's wayward in the sense that she can't make up her mind, or rather that she is attracted to both sexes.

    Further, he calls her Miss Private. From this we know she isn't married, but also that some part of her life is kept secret to some extent- her sexuality. Now look at the third stanza. Her family, in a friendly yet assertive manner, is telling the male that he will be good for her. Perhaps they know about her sexuality- he will be better for her than another female. What's really important in this stanza, however, is the last line: "Maybe, but not what she deserves." He realizes that he may care for her well, but in reality she deserves someone that can truly love her, and someone that she can truly love as well. He can't give her this.

    On a different note, look at the very first stanza. "How many nights of talking in hotel rooms can you take?" They've eloped; they're supposed to be madly in love, yet they are simply talking in the hotel room. I think this is a reference to the "pretend" nature of their relationship, in that, while they may care for each other, neither is in it for love.

    This is further explained in the last line in the fourth stanza, where the bedroom they share is "virginal". Lastly, look at the spelling of "heroine". He is not referring to the drug, which is spelled "heroin", but rather an important, courageous woman: "heroine". More importantly, she is his "heroine pretend", meaning that she is not the love of his life, the woman who has captured his attention, but rather simply a cover-up of sorts.

    At first I thought this song was about love. Now I believe this song is about a relationship between two individuals, neither heterosexual, who are about to enter into a phony romantic relationship. They still may care for each other and be friends, but they are not truly in love.
    Flag thoughts3on March 02, 2013   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:To me the song is a story about the youth of a relationship, and how it contrasts to married life. At the start of the song the guy falls in love with a girl and goes travelling with her, the highlight of these travels being San Francisco. He talks about the culture of San Francisco at the time and how they don't need anywhere to stay as they love one another. He describes the magical moment when she tells him about his favourite book. He then realises he loves her and has "responsibilities" and so marries her, possibly not because its what either of them actually want, but they feel they should.

    They go and tell the girl's family and they praise it, saying he will do a good job, he however starts to worry that she deserves better. They then go on their travels again but something's not quite the same, "continue this debate" suggests arguing and the fact that they're now staying in a bedroom shows how each other isn't enough anymore, and they need material goods to support their relationship.

    I don't believe the next part to have any relevance to baseball, but it's a metaphor for the downward spiral of their relationship, he however finds it too hard to talk about this directly and so covers it in the memories of a happier time; San Francisco. He talks about how hard life is out of the diamond, symbolising their move away from San Francisco and how they're finding their relationship difficult back on home ground. The drink reference (and heroine reference later) could symbolise that the couple are so depressed that they turn to drink and drugs.

    In the final stanza, the girl has left the boy and so he follows her over to San Francisco in hope that the romantic setting (the place where she told of him of her saddest book) will be enough to rekindle the romance. The end result is up to you; perhaps their relationship was only good in its youth, and they are not meant for each other, and so don't reunite. Or perhaps San Francisco does hold a magical quality that holds the two together, and they are able to live their days out together in the city in which they fell in love.
    Flag piazzanycon February 27, 2013   Link
  • 0
    My Interpretation:I think the "life outside the diamond is a wrench" part is talking about the baseball player realizing how confusing, tough, and stressful life outside his area of comfort (baseball) really is, and getting involved in things just makes him wish he could go back to just being int he diamond all the time and not having to worry about anything other than just playing the game he knows?
    Flag MrBigCheeson February 05, 2013   Link
  • 0
    Song Meaning:i always thought this was a reference to 'catcher in the rye', lines line 'How many nights of talking in hotel rooms can you take?' and the idea of eloping gave me this impression, like when holden meets sally in the book, maybe it's because i am english and know nothing about baseball...
    Flag hanginginthewireon June 13, 2012   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:I am reading "Stone Butch Blues" which is an biography by Leslie Feinburg about a butch (she refers to herself this way) woman's unbelievably harsh experiences-some occurring at bars in New York-usually in the Tenderloin. This song always comes to mind when I read the book because the book is probably one of the saddest I have ever read. I always wonder if he is referring to this book, which came out in the early 90s.
    Flag Buffy512on May 15, 2012   Link
  • 0
    My Opinion:I thought the Ferdinand to which the song refers might be Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Austria, the man whose assassination sparked World War One. He fell in love with a countess named Sophie, and because she was a countess and he an heir to the throne, Ferdinand's father forbid them to marry. Ferdinand went through with the marriage anyway, and his father declared the marriage morganatic, meaning that the children of that union would never be heirs to the throne. (source: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/…)

    I thought they might be referring to him in the song because of the part where he says she would be his "wayward girl" - I took that to mean a forbidden love situation like Franz Ferdinand's.

    Just a thought!
    Flagged secretskeepyousickon January 30, 2012   Link
  • +2
    General Comment:This makes me think of The Graduate for some reason. It's probably the idea of running away with a spouse (against the consent of parents), and being intrigued with having no idea what the future holds next.
    Flag pinkerton1229on October 30, 2011   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:Having read this I thought it was very informative. I appreciate you taking the time and effort to put this article together. I once again find myself spending way to much time both reading and commenting. But so what, it was still worth it!
    =======================

    gov-auctions.org" rel="dofollow">buy cheap cars
    Flagged ashleybrown088on April 11, 2011   Link
  • +1
    General Comment:Congratulations on the baseball interpretations, and thank you because learned something from it. But, I see the baseball story as a contextual background to the real affair that is taking place here between two good friends, or unnattached aquaintences. Whatever the case, the guy is clearly in love with someone who may or may not be likewise interested and he just doesn't know. He's throwing it out there with this song in a passionate attempt tell the gril how he truly feels win her heart. My opinion is that she is dating someone else, and possibly a friend and is unavailable. There is a very complex play on words throughout this wonderful song I may elaborate on my theory, but here are a few items of interest for the curious researcher. "Piazza, New York, Catcher" Piazza is a plaza, usually with a statue. New York is the setting of the story. Catcher or "Catch Her" and a reference throughout to the 'saddest book she ever read' Catcher in The Rye. (Note: Rye is a type of whiskey with which the catcher of this song seems to have a problem). Similar references here to the singer perhaps feeling himself to be like Salinger's Holden. They may be much more to this angle, the statues in the last reference NOT being that of Willy but rather the eskimos and that is where she should meet him in an hour after she hears this proposal. This last bit is a strech but someone else may be able to elaborate... consider that Ferdinand was the King of Spain and betrouthed to Isabel who was rumored to be having an affair with Columbus who thus sailed west. Isabel believed to be in love with another man, would make her perhaps Ferdinand's wayward girl, should she refuse and continue pining for her adventurer. Theres much to work with in this song.
    Flag lizardsagainon March 30, 2011   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:Thank you all for your interpretations, I like thinking about all the possible meanings of these songs. Especially Belle and Sebastian's, since their songs hardly ever seem to be straightforward. To me, I think there are three main topics in this song, being a love that needs to remain hidden (I think there are gay references, but the song leaves interpretation open for a non-gay forbidden love), obviously baseball and there's also references to books (Franny and Zooey and Catcher in the Rye see Deaf Junkie 88's comment) and maybe movies.

    I think the baseball references are a framework, it seems typically B&S to take sport metaphors to tell a story about something else. Actually, this elegant way of telling a story is the thing I like best about B&S. The book/movie references seem to be there to make the lyrics more elaborate: in the end it is impossible to tell a 200 page story in three minutes of a song, but by making these references you can (sort of)!
    Flag Bruuton June 27, 2010   Link

Add your thoughts

Log in now to tell us what you think this song means.

Don’t have an account? Create an account with SongMeanings to post comments, submit lyrics, and more. It’s super easy, we promise!

Back to top
explain