I live in America
With a pair of Payless shoes
The upper penisula
And the television news
And I've seen my wife
At the K-Mart
In strange ideas
We live apart

I live in a trailer home
With a snow mobile, my car
The window is broken out
And the interstate is far
I drove all night
To find my child
In strange ideas
He's been reviled

In strange ideas
In stranger times
I've no idea
What's right sometimes
I lost my mind
I lost my life
I lost my job
I lost my wife



Lyrics submitted by antennas

Track duration: 02:45


The Upper Peninsula song meanings
Add your thoughts

32 Comments

sort form View by:
  • 0
    My Interpretation:I live about three hours from, and have been to the UP on several occasions so I feel the need to comment. I think that the UP is very peaceful and absolutely beautiful, but not for everyone. If you can't appreciate being alone with nature, than stay in the city. I think he actually says he lost his job and wife in the last few lines of the song. This song definitely conveys a feeling of loneliness and solitude. I knew a guy who had a small hunting/snowmobiling trailer in a very remote area of Michigan and he had to live in it after he got divorced. Maybe this could be a similar situation.
    Flag NMELEVENon March 31, 2010   Link
  • 0
    My Opinion:Sufjan is not from the U.P. He grew up in Detroit, then moved to Petoskey.
    This song is so very sad to me. Beautiful musically, but the lyrics are disheartening. But they also reflect the state most people live in. Hopelessness.
    Flag nightswimming89on August 24, 2009   Link
  • +1
    General Comment:Funny how a song with such few, short lines has such passionate repsonses.
    Flag Chamoseson June 28, 2009   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:just read how this could have been inspired by his dad as well. so the lost child could be sufjan, and there could be a 'knowable' interpretation for other parts of the song as well... with research.
    Flag Joshua27on April 17, 2009   Link
  • +1
    General Comment:all in my opinion...

    v1: patriotism, generic strip mall consumerism, t.v. news and K-mart. the background is set - lower/middle class, low population town of the typical consumer. in this case the town also carries the stigma of having once thrived and is now decidely not doing so. and although i'm sure the u.p. is beautiful and peaceful, i don't believe the character in the song is experiencing it as such. this other side of the scene is also set here in verse one - a man who sees his wife, with in the very least this barrier of 'strange ideas', the recurring point in the song, between them. the ideas that they are divorced, that they are so distant they bump into one another at the store, or that he watches her indulging in her consumerism from an almost out-of-body perspective because he is so unable to connect with that consumerism are all possibilities, none concretely 'provable'. they also do not really effect the theme of the song - this man feels a distance from his wife, caused or worsened by his/these 'strange ideas, and on some level noticing a certain banality in his environment. (again, this isn't picking on the u.p. - the first line is 'I live in America' and this scene could happen many places in this country.)
    v2: further personalize scene - this guy's life sucks. live's in a trailer, it's winter and he's plowin snow when he drives it's so high, broken window in his ride to boot and the journey is gonna be long, he lives out in the middle of nowhere. second part is his strange ideas again, this time causing his child (literal or figurative, again is not really important or truly knowable) that he has put a lot of time into 'finding'. whether this is his inner child, a metaphor for a dream or ideal he once had, a christian image suddenly from a God/Christ perspective not being able to find him through his 'strange ideas', or literal are all not specifically important and can possible be all of the above. point is these 'strange ideas' have come between him and something he loves again.
    v3: bringing it back to the strange ideas. the times we live in are even stranger. they are strange, in a negative way, to a christian/spiritual worldview. they are strange, as in counterintuitive, from a philosophical, universally humanitarian and/or ecologically responsible viewpoint. they are, for whatever the reason strange to him much like the strange ideas he has/hears. he is confused by the world around him not corresponding to what he thinks and feels. he had it all but it was all rooted in the fleshly world, which cannot be counted on to comfort and protect us. he, much like the u.p., has lost his former glory.
    great song, great lament, great personification of a part of this nation. and nice, subtle nudge in the direction of hope.
    Flag Joshua27on April 17, 2009   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:This song is about Sufjan's dad. Sufjan lived with him for a while in the Upper Peninsula. You can read about it in Sufjan's essay How I Trumped Rudolph Lieberstein. look it up online.
    Flag madkayeon December 05, 2008   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:i've never been to to the UP but to me this song means what is probably seen in the UP but also all around america..the life of the lower middle class life that is prevalent. "I LIve in AmericA" is such a great line because America is this great land where you are supposed to be rich and prosperous but there are countless white americans who live like this. buying payless shoes, going to kmart, divorced, rebellious children. it sort of distorts the american dream into what it really is for those non immigrants. its not about extreme poverty but the the depression of the lower middle class white family. AMERICA!
    Flag avillatoon September 25, 2008   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:As a resident of the Upper Peninsula I would sadly say this is actually inaccurate. Theres the same majority of poor people here as there is anywhere else. I think a lot of people get the misconception that we're all hicks using outhouses and aside from the hunters this is untrue. Still a great song though.
    Flag abrighteyeon November 03, 2007   Link
  • 0
    General Comment:I'm from the U.P. & a damn proud Yooper. Yeah, there's unemployment but there is EVERWHERE & some people are content to live in small houses in the woods, but that's not everyone. Yeah, I live in Marquette, the most populated area, but I don't think he's singing about the U.P. in the sense you all think. Listening to this song I think of driving in the wintertime.. it's great to see people embrace their surroundings & the outdoors in one of the most beautiful places in the world.
    Flag nagz88on October 11, 2007   Link
  • +2
    General Comment:songmeanings.com - not listentosongsbutdon'tthinkaboutheirmeanings.com
    Flag klauber901on August 29, 2007   Link

Add your thoughts

Log in now to tell us what you think this song means.

Don’t have an account? Create an account with SongMeanings to post comments, submit lyrics, and more. It’s super easy, we promise!

Back to top
explain